Going First in a Negotiation Can Help — Here’s When

Russell Newton explores the anchoring strategy from Albert Rutherford’s ‘The Game Theory of Negotiation’—and why going first in negotiation is such a powerful move in every negotiation. Learn the anchor psychology behind setting the opening number, how it influences the entire negotiation, and why understanding behavioral economics gives you a dealmaking edge. Discover how to build a confident range before naming a number for maximum impact.

⏱ CHAPTERS
0:00 Intro
3:06 Inherited Sculpture Example
4:10 Two Ideas from Book
5:45 Maravi and Levy Negotiation Study
7:25 Unpaid Work Contribution Scenario
9:11 The Pie Test Explanation

If you’re diving into personal development and want to master the art of negotiations, don’t miss out on Russell Newton’s insights! From his audiobook narration expertise to his deep dives into anchor psychology and game theory, Russell shares invaluable negotiation tactics that can help you win more deals and communicate effectively in business. Whether it’s understanding anchoring strategies or avoiding the pitfalls of lowball offers, Russell Eric Newton breaks down complex concepts with clarity and wisdom from behavioral economics expert Albert Rutherford.

you
you
When my parents died, I inherited a sculpture, a bronze mid-century signed torso of a woman.
I posted a photo of it online once out of curiosity.
Within two days, an art dealer called.
He came by, examined it carefully, checked the signature twice, then he asked what I was looking for.
I had no idea what the sculpture was worth, but I named a number anyway.
Ambitious, I figured, but not absurd.
He said he’d think about it.
He never called back.
I had it appraised, and later learned I’d anchored about a quarter of what it was actually worth.
That’s the opening of Albert Rutherford’s new book, The Game Theory of Negotiation.
It’s not my story, it’s his.
Now I’m narrated close to 15 of his books, and this is one of the ideas in it that actually changed how I think about going first in a negotiation.
Two ideas from the book today.
One about what you don’t know going in.
One about how you frame what you’re fighting over.
Here’s the thing about that sculpture story.
And I wish he’d given us a little more background on whether that dealer thought he was a fraud or was afraid to rip him off.
You know, I’m curious about that one, but that’s not in the book.
Now, Rutherford didn’t lose any money going first.
He just didn’t know enough to go first well.
Now, he backs that up with a much bigger example.
HP’s $11.1 billion acquisition of a company called Autonomy in 2011.
That $11.1 billion was a 79% premium over the going market price.
15 months later, HP wrote down $8.8 billion of it, alleging autonomy’s revenue had been inflated.
So whatever the legal outcome, that fight ran for over a decade.
The structural problem was visible before any lawsuit.
HP set the price on a business they didn’t fully understand.
Now, autonomy’s team knew their own numbers, but HP didn’t.
And that gap wasn’t incidental to what happened.
It was what happened.
Going first when you don’t know enough isn’t bold.
It’s a gift to the other side.
Brotherford backs that with research too.
Maravi and Levy tested it across negotiation scenarios.
When both sides know roughly the same amount, going first helps.
Once one side knows more, going first hurts the less informed party.
They low ball themselves, or they hand the other side a clear read on exactly how little they know.
So what do you actually do?
Rutherford’s answer applied in the book through a guy chasing a rare vintage guitar he’d hunted for two years.
Before naming any number, spend 30 minutes finding comparable sales, same item, similar condition, multiple sources, but a real range and anchor just under the bottom of it, evidence in hand.
If you can’t build a confident range, let the other side go first.
Their number is information your research couldn’t give you.
Going first is only an advantage when both sides know roughly the same amount.
When one side knows less, anchoring first hands the other side a read on that gap.
Before naming a number, build a real range or let the other informed side go first.
The second idea from Rutherford’s book is a completely different failure.
Not information.
Framing.
Two co-founders, two years into a software company.
One put in $200,000 in capital.
The other put in two years of full-time, unpaid work building the product.
Now they’re raising their first round.
Investors want the cap table clean.
And both founders are asking for 60% of the equity.
And it’s turned adversarial.
The equity number was never the real negotiation.
Rutherford calls this the pie test, treating equity in this case as one fixed pie that has to be divided, when the actual structure is far more flexible than that.
Neither founder could move without feeling like they were conceding their own contribution didn’t matter.
Here’s the reframe that breaks it.
What does the capital partner need that costs the other side nothing?
Recognizing she carried real financial risk, she could have lost that $200,000 outright.
What does the other founder need that costs her nothing?
Recognition that two years of unpaid work is what actually built the value the capital is now funding.
Those needs aren’t competing.
Once you see that, you’re not negotiating a number anymore.
You’re designing a structure.
vesting schedules, split ownership between capital and sweat equity, profit sharing that adjusts over time.
Now here’s the line that stuck with me.
At some point, someone has to say out loud that any movement feels like admitting their contribution didn’t matter because naming that instead of just feeling it is what actually unlocks the room.
The pie test.
Treating a negotiation as one fixed pie makes a solvable problem look zero sum.
Ask what each side needs that costs the other side nothing.
The real negotiation is often a structure, not a single number.
An anchor you set without enough information, a pie you assumed was fixed when it wasn’t, two different traps, same result, you end up negotiating the wrong thing.
If either one sounds like something you’re sitting on right now, that’s the book.
The Game Theory of Negotiation by Albert Rutherford.
New release, narrated by me.
Available now wherever you get your audiobooks.
You may recall I did a separate episode on what it was actually like narrating this one.
Links below in the comments if you want to see that side of it.
Subscribe if this was useful.
More of these are going up regularly.

Leave a Reply